Great Train Expo I went to the Great Train Expo in Collinsville, Illinois today, and I came home with only two ads for a couple of upcoming train shows in the Greater St. Louis area. Needless to say, I was disappointed with this year's show.
Let me do a little venting:I usually head out early for the Thanksgiving Weekend show, but I decided to go later in the afternoon this year. It was not real crowded, a plus for me, but probably not for the vendors. If you have ever attended a train show you know there is always a huge selection of toy trains (Lionel, American Flyer, MTH, etc.), as well as Bachmann and Life-Like Train sets. I noticed a lot of the train sets, but not as many new Lionel or MTH products that they usually have at this show. I also noticed a whole lot of overpriced Lionel products in fair to poor condition. In my honest opinion, a large portion of it looked like junk. I don't mean to sound harsh, but it seems like the quality of used Lionel products at these shows goes down every year.
I really went to this show to see if I could find some Scenic Express products, in particular, I was looking for Silflor Buffalo Grass. I did find some Scenic Express SuperTrees, but that was it. I also did not see a whole lot of scenery products from Woodland Scenics either. There was a small selection of some Bachmann scenery products and a few of the Life-Like trees (the ones that do not look very realistic). I did find a large selection of figures, but most of these were only priced a little under MSRP.
I also visited one of the vendors who carries all of the cool tools for model building. They have a huge selection, but the economy has certainly affected their prices. I purchased a NWSL Chopper 2 from them last year, and the price this year is $3.00 higher than what I paid for it in 2008. I am sure glad I made that purchase last year, although I could have gotten it cheaper through mail order/Internet. They are still one of my favorite vendors to visit (one of the highlights of the show).
Now for some praise:I also like to look at the train layouts that are on display and I really enjoy looking at the ones that come to this show in Collinsville. The NTrak club layout and the HO modular layout are some of my favorites to view. I believe the NTrak group is the
Mississippi Valley N Scalers. One of my favorite modules is the one that has a tornado ripping through town (remember, I am also a weather freak). That module just blows me away (no pun intended,---
well, maybe a little!).
This year's show had a few vendors who were selling videos. They had a great selection and their prices were really good too. I gave some thought to buying one, but I was not really in the market to buy a video. I wish now I would have bought one!!!
If you were looking for locomotives and freight/passenger cars, then this show would have been for you. Several vendors had a good selection of locomotives and cars at fairly reasonable prices. A definite positive for those looking to add to their respective fleets.
Here's how I graded this year's show:- Lionel/Toy Train Items: D (not for quantity, but for quality and new products)
- Locomotives/Freight Cars/Passenger Cars: A-
- Scenery Materials: F
- Train Sets: A-
- Videos: A-
- Model Tools: B- (for price, not selection)
- Ease of Viewing Vendor Items: B+
- Display Layouts: A
- Parking: B
- Admission Price: D (I think it is too high)
- Vendor Prices: C+ (the bad economy keeps this from being a lower grade)
Overall grade is a B-
I look forward to the Railroad Swap Meet hosted by the Boeing Employees' Railroad Club of St. Louis on March 13, 2010. Their show is not as large as The Great Train Expo, but they usually have a great selection of scale products.
Thanks for visiting and happy modeling!
Tom